Get a second estimate when the insurer’s number looks too low, when a shop tells you the damage is bigger than the report says, or when the two figures are far apart. No state law requires you to collect a set number of estimates, but one estimate from a shop you trust is the best test of whether the insurer’s figure will actually fix your car. If the real repair bill also leaves you short on the deductible, we can check your eligibility for deductible assistance for free, with no obligation.
TL;DR
- An adjuster’s estimate is a starting benchmark, not a final payment. A second estimate from your own shop tells you whether it covers the full repair.
- No law sets how many estimates you must submit, and you generally choose the repair shop. If your shop charges more than the insurer’s suggested shop, you may owe the difference.
- If the numbers still differ, you can negotiate with the adjuster, and many policies include an appraisal process for disputes over the amount of damage.
- The deductible comes out of the settlement on every claim, so a higher repair figure does not raise your deductible. It only raises what the insurer pays.
- If you cannot cover the deductible, ask about help before you authorize repairs.
Table of Contents
- What a second estimate actually does
- When you should get a second estimate
- Do you have to get more than one estimate?
- Who picks the repair shop
- How to compare the two estimates, step by step
- If the insurer and your shop still disagree
- What a higher estimate means for your deductible
- Vandalism, storms and other no-fault damage
- A worked example
- If you cannot cover the deductible
- Our perspective
- Getting help with the deductible
- FAQ
- Sources
What a second estimate actually does
After a collision, vandalism or storm, your insurer sends an adjuster, or asks for photos, and writes up an estimate of what the repair should cost. The Insurance Information Institute (III), an insurance industry education group, explains that the adjuster’s estimate is a benchmark rather than a total claim payment. It also says insurers expect you to bring at least one estimate from your own mechanic, garage or dealer to compare.
That comparison is the whole purpose of a second estimate. You are not doubting anyone. You are checking that the figure on paper matches the work your car needs: parts, labor, paint and any structural or hidden damage a quick photo review can miss.
The III also notes that the insurer may pay the lowest bid, and that it can insist on more than one estimate if it believes yours is too high. So the estimate you bring should itemize the work. A single lump sum is easy to dispute; a line-by-line list of parts and labor is not.
When you should get a second estimate
Not every claim needs one. Here are the situations where it is worth the time.
The insurer’s number looks low
If the adjuster’s figure seems thin for the damage you can see, a repair shop’s written estimate is your evidence. The III says you can negotiate with the adjuster when the estimate is too low, and a shop’s itemized figure gives you something concrete to negotiate with.
The damage is more than a dent
Bumper covers, quarter panels, sensors and cameras hide damage behind the surface. Storm and hail damage often spreads across many panels. In these cases a shop that removes the panel and looks may find work the first estimate did not include. Ask the shop to list every item, and send the written list to your adjuster.
The two numbers are far apart
A small gap is normal. A large gap is a reason to find out which estimate is missing something. Ask both sides for the line items and compare them: which parts are listed, which repairs, how many labor hours.
The shop you want will not match the insurer’s figure
If your preferred shop quotes more than the insurer’s, ask the shop to send its estimate directly to the adjuster. Shops deal with this every day, and a written explanation of why a repair costs what it does often settles the difference without a fight.
You have a deductible you can barely cover
This one is easy to overlook. If the deductible already strains your budget, you need the full repair cost settled before you commit, because a surprise supplement or a dispute can delay the work for days. Sorting the amount out early lets you line up deductible help in time.
Do you have to get more than one estimate?
No. State regulators say so plainly. The Illinois Department of Insurance states that there is no law saying how many estimates you must submit, nor limiting how many the company can ask for. The South Dakota Division of Insurance says there is no state law requiring two estimates, though getting them is common and acceptable practice.
Rules vary by state, so check your own state’s department of insurance. The point holds broadly: a second estimate is a tool you choose to use, and your insurer may also ask for one.
South Dakota’s regulator adds that comparing estimates helps get the vehicle repaired at the lowest possible cost, which reduces claim costs and helps keep auto insurance rates down. That is why insurers do not treat a second estimate as an insult. It is routine.
Who picks the repair shop
You do, in most cases. Texas regulators state that you have the right to choose the repair shop and parts for your vehicle, though the insurer is not required to pay more than a reasonable amount. Pennsylvania’s claim-handling standards say an insurer may not require you to be repaired at specific shops or to travel unreasonably to get an estimate. Massachusetts law is similar: no insurer or appraiser may require repairs at a specific shop or from a list.
The catch is price. Illinois’s insurance department warns that if your chosen shop charges more than the company’s suggested shop, you may have to pay the difference. New Hampshire’s rule goes into detail: if the insurer and your independent shop cannot agree, payment may be limited to the price available from another competent, conveniently located shop, and you could owe the rest. The same rule also requires that the insurer’s offer reflect a fair and reasonable local price and that you be told you can use any repair shop.

This is why itemized estimates matter. When the difference is real work the first estimate left out, not just a higher hourly rate, you have a strong case that the insurer should pay it.
How to compare the two estimates, step by step
- Ask for the insurer’s estimate in writing. Pennsylvania’s standards require that the insurer give you a copy of its appraisal. Ask for yours in any state.
- Take it to the shop you trust. Ask them to inspect the car, ideally with the damaged areas exposed, and write an itemized estimate.
- Line the two up. Mark each difference: a part listed on one and not the other, labor hours, paint and refinishing, and whether parts are new, aftermarket or used.
- Send the shop’s estimate to your adjuster. Explain which lines differ and why. Keep the conversation factual. Our guide on how to talk to an insurance adjuster after car damage covers what to say and what to write down.
- Ask for a revised estimate. Adjusters can issue supplements when the shop finds more damage. Get any revision in writing.
- Keep the paper trail. Save photos, emails, claim numbers and names. If the dispute continues, you will need them.
If the insurer and your shop still disagree
Start by negotiating. If that fails, check your policy for an appraisal clause. The Texas Department of Insurance explains that in the appraisal process each side picks an appraiser, and the two appraisers can select a third to act as an umpire. The decision is binding on the amount of the damage, while disputes about whether something is covered are handled separately. Texas’s draft consumer rules add that either you or the insurer may demand appraisal to resolve a dispute over the amount to repair or replace damaged property.
Appraisal costs money and time, so it fits big gaps, not a few hundred dollars. For many drivers, a clear itemized comparison and a polite, documented request settles the matter first. If you believe the claim has been handled unfairly, your state department of insurance takes consumer complaints and can tell you what your state’s rules say.
What a higher estimate means for your deductible
Here is the part that surprises people. A higher second estimate does not change your deductible. Your deductible is the amount you agree to pay before the insurer pays the rest. Indiana’s Department of Insurance gives the example: with a $200 deductible and a $500 loss, you pay $200 and the insurer pays $300. If the real loss is $1,500 instead, you still pay $200 and the insurer pays $1,300.
So a correct estimate works in your favor: the insurer carries the extra cost, not you. The deductible comes out of the settlement each time you file a claim.
One warning matters here. Illinois’s insurance department says insurers treat it as fraud if a repair shop offers to increase the estimate to help you recover your deductible. Never ask a shop to pad a number to cover what you owe. Estimates should reflect only the real damage and the real repair.
When someone else caused the damage
If another driver was at fault, your insurer may be able to recover your deductible from the other party. Under Texas’s draft rules, if another person may be liable and you paid or owe a deductible, your insurer must act to recover it within one year of claim payment, refund it, or tell you it will not act so you can try yourself. Other states have their own timelines. For the practical first steps after a crash, see what to do after an auto accident, and ask your insurer in writing whether it will pursue recovery of your deductible. Our article on fault and no-fault claims and who still pays a deductible explains how fault changes what you owe.
Vandalism, storms and other no-fault damage
With vandalism, hail, falling trees, floods or animal strikes, there is usually no other driver to recover from, so the deductible is yours. Storm damage is also where second estimates earn their keep, because damage is spread across the car and shops are busy. If you are dealing with fire or ash, read our guides on wildfire car deductible help and the wildfire ash car insurance deductible. A parked car hit by someone who drove off is covered in parked car hit claim steps.
If you only damaged your own car with no other party involved, single-vehicle accident deductible help explains what you owe and how to cover it.
A worked example
Say a driver in Los Angeles County backs into a pole and her insurer’s adjuster writes an estimate of $1,900 from photos. Her deductible is $500. Her shop removes the bumper cover and finds a cracked sensor bracket and a damaged reinforcement bar, and writes an itemized estimate of $2,700.
She sends the shop’s list to the adjuster, who approves the added items. The insurer’s payment rises from $1,400 (the $1,900 estimate minus her $500 deductible) to $2,200 (the $2,700 estimate minus the same $500). Her deductible did not move. What changed is that the repair is now fully paid, and the shop does not stop work to wait for money she does not have.

The figures are illustrative, not a quote, but the arithmetic is how deductibles work.
If you cannot cover the deductible
The second estimate sorts out how much the insurer pays. It does not help with what you pay. Many drivers skip a needed repair, drive a damaged car, or put the deductible on a high-interest card because they cannot find the cash at once.
Before you do that, look at your options. Our guides on ways to cover a deductible you cannot afford, deductible payment plans and how to file a claim without paying the deductible walk through each path. If you have no coverage at all, see repairing your car after an accident without insurance.
Our perspective
We see the second estimate as a way to protect two things: the repair itself and your budget. A fair estimate means the car gets fixed properly and the insurer pays its share, not you.
What we want drivers to understand is that the estimate and the deductible are separate problems. The estimate decides how much the insurer pays. The deductible is your share, and for many people it is the part that blocks the repair. A driver who has won a fair estimate but cannot pay the deductible is still stuck.
That is the reason Deductible Assist exists. We help drivers who are struggling with deductibles after collisions, vandalism, natural disasters or animal damage. Our process has three steps: a prequalification application, expert guidance, and deductible support for qualified applicants. Each applicant has a dedicated case handler, and the eligibility check is free and carries no obligation.
Our advice is simple. Get your estimates in order, and deal with the deductible at the same time, not after the shop has already called.
Mikayel
Getting help with the deductible
If the deductible is what stands between you and the repair, we can help. Deductible Assist offers assistance with car insurance deductibles after accidents, vandalism, natural disasters and animal damage. You start with a prequalification application, receive expert guidance through the claim process, and, if you qualify, get financial support toward the deductible. Checking your eligibility is free and without obligation. You can read how it works in our three-step deductible assistance process.

Bring the written estimate and your claim number when you apply; they help your case handler see where your claim stands. Our auto claim steps guide shows what to do in what order so repairs keep moving without adding bad debt.
FAQ
Is it worth getting a second estimate if my insurer already sent one?
Usually yes, when the damage looks bigger than the report or the number seems low. The Insurance Information Institute says the adjuster’s figure is a benchmark and that insurers expect you to compare it with an estimate from your own shop. For a small, clear dent, one estimate may be enough.
Can my insurer force me to use its preferred shop?
In the states we checked, no. Texas, Pennsylvania and Massachusetts all say you may choose your shop, and insurers may not require a specific one. If your shop costs more than the insurer’s suggested shop, you may have to pay the difference, so ask for itemized estimates.
Does a higher estimate raise my deductible?
No. Your deductible is a fixed amount you agree to in your policy, and it is subtracted from the settlement. A higher, accurate estimate increases what the insurer pays, not what you owe. Never ask a shop to inflate a number to recover a deductible, because insurers consider that fraud.
What if I cannot afford the deductible even after the estimate is settled?
Talk to us before you authorize repairs. We offer a free, no-obligation eligibility check, and qualified applicants can receive financial support for the deductible, with a dedicated case handler to guide the process.
Sources
- Illinois Department of Insurance: Filing a Claim with Your Own Insurance Company
- South Dakota Division of Insurance: Consumer Information, Automobile
- Insurance Information Institute: Determining your car’s value and cost of repair
- Texas Department of Insurance: What if my insurance isn’t paying enough?
- Texas Department of Insurance: 2026 draft consumer rights figure
- 31 Pa. Code § 146.8
- Mass. General Laws c.90 § 34O
- N.H. Admin. Code § Ins 1002.17
- Indiana Department of Insurance: Consumer Guide to Auto Insurance

Leave a Reply